0038. 0038 — Credits never expire
Status: accepted 2026-11-12. Supersedes the expiry rule in ADR 0017.
Context
Section titled “Context”ADR 0017 had subscription grants expire at the period end. org_credit_balance dropped expired
grants but kept every debit, so a subscriber who spent a month’s grant lost the same amount again
at renewal. The owner also moved billing to one plan (€9 per editor per month, 500 credits) and
top-ups.
Decision
Section titled “Decision”- No credit expires: monthly grants, top-ups, welcome and refund grants stay until spent.
org_credit_balancesums every grant minus every debit (20261112_credits_never_expire.sql). Renewal grants are written withoutexpires_at, and their amount ismetadata.credits × invoice line quantity.org_credits_at_riskis dropped; nothing is at risk.- Store grants may still carry
expires_at; the balance ignores it.
Consequences
Section titled “Consequences”Unspent monthly credits carry over. The pglite harness npm run test:credit-expiry runs the real
SQL and fails if a spent grant again eats a renewal.